Episode 43: Why Emotional Eating Won't Budge No Matter What You Try | Trauma, the Nervous System and the Wellness Merry-Go-Round

This episode and article contain discussions around emotional eating, disordered eating, restriction, trauma, and the binge cycle. Please engage gently. This content is educational in nature and reflects personal experience and clinical perspective. It is not intended to replace medical, psychological, or mental health support. If you are struggling with an eating disorder or severe distress around food or your body, please reach out to a qualified healthcare professional or contact an eating disorder support service in your region.

‍ ‍

If you have tried everything and you keep finding yourself back at the beginning, starting again, I want you to understand something. This is not an accident. That is by design.

Today I want to talk about something that doesn't get said nearly enough. Not about what you're eating or your nervous system, although we get there too. What I want to talk about is why you keep going back.

When I was deep in my own cycle around food, I went through a period where I was trying very hard to stay in a calorie deficit. Just what every diet and eating plan tells you to do. And what happened to my body when I did that was not what I expected.

It didn't matter how small the deficit was. It didn't matter if I was being sensible about it. The moment my body registered that it wasn't getting enough, my whole system would flood with cortisol. I would feel it physically. My back muscles would seize up, my neck and shoulders would become so tense that it caused physical pain. Not just discomfort. A full body bracing, a physical holding that wouldn't release until I ate again.

And I remember thinking, what is wrong with me? Why is this so hard? Why does something that seems so simple for other people feel like this for me?

The answer I now understand is that I grew up with a lot of relational trauma. And a body that has lived through relational trauma doesn't experience restriction the way a regulated, supported, and well-resourced body does. For my nervous system, restriction wasn't just uncomfortable. It was a threat signal. And my body responded accordingly.

I want you to hold that story while I explain something about the industry that has been selling you solutions for years.

The Poker Machine Model

The wellness industry runs on the same psychology as a poker machine. I want you to really sit with that for a moment.

If you've ever seen research on gambling addiction, you'll know about something called intermittent reinforcement. It is one of the most powerful psychological mechanisms ever studied.

Here's how it works. You pull a lever and nothing happens, you stop pulling. You pull a lever and something always happens, you get bored and stop pulling. But when you pull a lever and sometimes you win, sometimes you don't, sometimes the reward is big and sometimes it's small, sometimes it doesn't come at all but you cannot stop pulling. The unpredictability is the addiction. The occasional win is what keeps you going back. Not the consistent outcome. The possibility of one.

This is how poker machines are designed. It is how social media is designed. The unpredictable scroll, the occasional post that makes you feel something, the algorithm that gives you just enough to keep you coming back. It is how gambling is designed. And it is, whether intentionally or not, exactly how the wellness and diet industry works.

You go on a plan. Maybe it works for a while. Maybe you feel better for a few weeks. You have a run of good days and that's the win. That's the lever playing out. And then it stops working. Or life gets in the way. Or you go on a holiday and come home feeling like you need to start over. And instead of concluding that the plan didn't work, your brain concludes that you need to pull the lever again. Because it worked last time. Maybe this time will be the big win. This time I'm going to get it right.

That determination, that I'm starting again and this time it's going to be different energy, is not a character flaw. That is one of the most well documented psychological responses in existence.

The wellness industry is a multi-billion dollar industry. And it stays that way because the product only works sometimes, for some people, temporarily. If it worked completely and permanently, you would never need to buy again. The merry-go-round is profitable. Your freedom from it is not.

The Neuroscience of Why This Cycle Is So Hard to Break

Your brain has a system driven by dopamine, centered in a region called the nucleus accumbens. Its job is to motivate you towards things that keep you alive. Food, connection, safety, novelty. It creates urgency, a pull, a seeking energy towards the things that matter.

Here's what happens when you restrict. Restriction is a physiological stressor. For some people it's a mild one. For others, particularly those with a history of trauma or chronic stress, it is significant. The body interprets a deficit not as a lifestyle choice but as a threat. Cortisol rises, the nervous system activates, the body begins scanning for resources.

When you finally eat, particularly something high reward and immediately satisfying, the dopamine response is significant. The seeking system in your brain finds what it was looking for. The cortisol drops. Your nervous system can exhale.

A binge doesn't just feel like relief emotionally. It is relief neurologically. Your brain registers it as the resolution of a threat.

This is why the restrict and binge cycle is so hard to interrupt through willpower alone. You're not fighting a bad habit. You're fighting a physiological sequence that your nervous system has learned very accurately produces relief.

And for a body carrying relational trauma, restriction doesn't just produce mild discomfort. It can produce something that feels like survival level distress. Physical pain. Full body tension. A cortisol response so significant that eating isn't just desired. It's the only thing that makes the pain stop.

And then we wonder why we can't just stick to the plan.

The Swimming Lessons

Here is the analogy I keep coming back to. Imagine someone hands you a meal plan, a protocol, a set of rules designed to change your relationship with food. And it works for a lot of people genuinely. For some women this is exactly what they need and it changes things.

But those women had swimming lessons.

Some women come to food plans with a regulated nervous system, a history of feeling safe, a body that doesn't interpret restriction as threat. They have the internal resources to follow that protocol. They have the emotional capacity to tolerate discomfort without their system flooding. They have the foundational safety that allows them to be in the water without panicking.

For women who didn't get those swimming lessons, food became their floaty. The thing that keeps them above water. The thing that regulates them when nothing else does. The thing that provides relief, comfort, numbing, or grounding, whatever that moment needs.

And when someone comes along and takes the floaty away and gives them a new plan instead, what they don't realise is that woman is now in the water without the one thing that was keeping her afloat. She's not struggling because she's weak. She was never given swimming lessons.

So she goes back to the lever. Because the last time it worked for a while, and maybe this time will be different. And the industry is right there with a new plan, a new protocol, a new version of the same thing with a different name. And the promise that this time is the one.

And the cycle continues.

What the Swimming Lessons Actually Look Like

This isn't about blaming the wellness industry entirely. Some of what exists in that space is genuinely helpful for the right people. Some practitioners are doing beautiful work. But if you are a woman who has been trying for years and you keep ending up back at the beginning, I want you to hear this clearly. The problem is not you. The problem is that you have been given bathing suits when what you actually needed was swimming lessons.

And until you get the swimming lessons, your floaty will keep being necessary. Not because you're weak. Because you're still in the water.

The swimming lessons look like going to the parts of you that learned to use food to cope and actually understanding what they've been doing and why. Not trying to stop them. Just understanding them. They look like building enough nervous system safety that a hard day doesn't automatically end in the kitchen. They look like healing the relational wounds that taught your system it wasn't safe to have needs, to want things, or to be supported. They look like getting off the merry-go-round, not by white-knuckling your way through another plan, but by no longer needing the plan in the first place.

And I want to say something about the floaty here. Getting the swimming lessons doesn't mean you'll never use a floaty again. There are seasons of life that are genuinely hard and you will reach for comfort and that is okay. The goal was never perfect eating or the permanent absence of hard days. The goal is that the floaty is no longer required for daily survival. That you can be in the water and in your life without needing it to keep you afloat every single day.

And that is what becomes possible when you do the real work.

If this episode resonated, please share it with a woman in your life who needs to hear it.

And if you're ready to get the swimming lessons, the link is in the show notes to book a free consultation with me.

The waitlist for Breaking the Emotional Eating Cycle is now open. Women who join before launch receive founding member pricing.